You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I think the reason tp_del isn't documented is that, as we somehow learnt it with the new IO code, it isn't really meant for third-party types.
I would suggest checking with python-dev.
As for tp_version_tag, it's for internal use (it indicated whether the method cache is still fresh), I don't think extension authors should modify it.
tp_cache and tp_weaklist are also for internal use only, but are
documented.
Ok, so I guess tp_version_tag and tp_del should also be documented as "for internal use only".
AlexLeach commented on Apr 20, 2013
AlexLeachmannequin
Mannequin
More actions
I've just ran into tp_version_tag, when running the boost python testsuite and wondered what it was... Since upgrading to GCC 4.8, I've started to get a lot more warnings with Python extensions, e.g.:-
boost/python/opaque_pointer_converter.hpp:122:14: warning: missing initializer for member ‘_typeobject::tp_version_tag’ [-Wmissing-field-initializers]
In this instance the testsuite was made to compile with the '-Wextra' flag. The fix was pretty simple; add another zero to the opaque_pointer_convert struct.
I have used the following preprocessor macro to test whether or not to do this. Would this be a good way to test for the addition?
In my opinion, tp_del corresponds to the __del__() method of classes, because there are no other variable correspondes to it, but methods using for creating(tp_new) and initializing(tp_init) an object are not.
Although __del__ method have some issue according to the offical document, but it is exist, so there must have a pointer to the function corresponding to it.
Activity
stutzbach commentedon Jan 13, 2009
The PyTypeObject field "tp_version_tag" (new in 2.6) isn't documented.
"tp_del" isn't documented either. I'm not sure when it was added.
pitrou commentedon Jul 31, 2010
I think the reason tp_del isn't documented is that, as we somehow learnt it with the new IO code, it isn't really meant for third-party types.
I would suggest checking with python-dev.
As for tp_version_tag, it's for internal use (it indicated whether the method cache is still fresh), I don't think extension authors should modify it.
ronaldoussoren commentedon Jan 22, 2013
tp_cache and tp_weaklist are also for internal use only, but are documented.
One reason for documenting them is that users will run into them when running with a high enough warning level in GCC.
pitrou commentedon Jan 23, 2013
Ok, so I guess tp_version_tag and tp_del should also be documented as "for internal use only".
AlexLeach commentedon Apr 20, 2013
I've just ran into tp_version_tag, when running the boost python testsuite and wondered what it was... Since upgrading to GCC 4.8, I've started to get a lot more warnings with Python extensions, e.g.:-
boost/python/opaque_pointer_converter.hpp:122:14: warning: missing initializer for member ‘_typeobject::tp_version_tag’ [-Wmissing-field-initializers]
In this instance the testsuite was made to compile with the '-Wextra' flag. The fix was pretty simple; add another zero to the opaque_pointer_convert struct.
I have used the following preprocessor macro to test whether or not to do this. Would this be a good way to test for the addition?
Cheers,
Alex
bookbook commentedon May 12, 2018
tp_del still undocumented.
In my opinion, tp_del corresponds to the __del__() method of classes, because there are no other variable correspondes to it, but methods using for creating(tp_new) and initializing(tp_init) an object are not.
Although __del__ method have some issue according to the offical document, but it is exist, so there must have a pointer to the function corresponding to it.
pitrou commentedon May 12, 2018
The reason tp_del has remained undocumented is that it's now obsolete. You should use tp_finalize instead:
https://docs.python.org/3/c-api/typeobj.html#c.PyTypeObject.tp_finalize
tp_finalize is roughly the C equivalent of __del__ (tp_del was something else, despite the name).
pitrou commentedon May 12, 2018
Both tp_del and tp_version_tag are for internal use. Besides, tp_del is obsolete as I mentioned above. So I'm going to close the issue.